Wikidata:Edit groups/QSv2/34522
Edit group QSv2/34522
| Summary | {{{summary}}} | Author | Exec8 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of edits | 3,270 (more statistics) | Example edit | Q155396 |
Discussion edit
@Exec8: Hello. Thank you for your great contributions in Wikidata and Wikipedia. However, previous discussion in Wikipedia Tambayan Philippines showed that elevation must be removed as it is sourced from PhilAtlas. User Psiĥedelisto even went far as to report the site in Spam blacklist, which was immediately accepted by an administrator without further discussion if the site warrants being put under spam blacklist. Though I personally find PhilAtlas not very authoritative, I still see that the elevation figures from that site are accurate when double-checking in other more authoritative sources. You later added viewfinderpanoramas.org as a source, though PhilAtlas does not explicitly state that it sourced its elevation from that site.
I was thinking of reverting your Quickstatements batch which added the elevation data, but I do not know if further discussion should be initiated here in Wikidata regarding PhilAtlas data, since I am not sure if Wikipedia and Wikidata have different policies regarding reliable sources.
I would want to know what you can say about this, and if your batch addition of the elevation data should indeed be reverted. –Sanglahi86 (talk) 10:50, 28 June 2020 (UTC)