Topic on User talk:Emu

Summary by Emu

user directed to page for complaint

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

You exactly said "@Palaangelino: I’m sorry but a Commons category link isn't proof of notability, see Wikidata:Notability #1.4. I just checked a couple of the links you provided. All seem user-generated or sponsored. Is there any independent, serious coverage about any of the items in question?" in the request of deletion page. I don't want to take this personal as Wikimedia Project leads us to. So I want to know the logic behind your saying "all seem" if you only checked some. How have you been sure about all, if you checked some?

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

Addition to your answer, I prolly need another administrator to this conversation also to check if something is weird.

Emu (talkcontribs)

@Palaangelino: The “all” refers to all the links I checked. I know there is some semantic ambiguity but I do think that this is clear from context. I don‘t really understand what you are trying to say with the “I don't want to take this personal as Wikimedia Project leads us to.“ and the “if something is weird.” parts of your messages, please clarify.

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

I thought you're making a mistake by generalizing my all items and references. Do you have any connection outer Wikimedia with any of these users? Or have you involved in any conversation about your message over my items that I don't know. Cuz you're clearly generalizing by adding the words "...any of the items in question?" so the "all" which is coming just before the "any of the items" refers to all items. Cuz you want me to provide references for any of the items in question which is all.

Emu (talkcontribs)

I’d like to respectfully remind you that accusations without any proof may be grounds for a block. I’d also like to remind you that WD:RFD is here to discuss the notability of items and the items in question were created by you.

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

If you're going to say "...any of the items in question?" refers to items that are referenced by user-generated or sponsored content which are "some" references that you mentioned, that's also non-sense. Cuz you didn't say any item names or reference numbers specifically which leads "...any of the items in question?" to all items again. Cuz I don't know which one you're questioning at all. I really need another admin here.

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

I'm not judging you. You're judging me and my items here by generalizing all which is non-sense. I'm just curious and asking directly to you.

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

Don't get me wrong. I'm looking for a logic and a third eye.

Emu (talkcontribs)

I think I clarified what I meant. If you feel you are unfairly treated: I doubt that many administrators are avid readers of my talk page. You might want to express your concerns about my behavior on WD:AN.

Palaangelino (talkcontribs)

Ok, thanks. I'll.