User:Mateusz Konieczny/failing testcases/Archive 8
Green Mountains (Q41507) is a science, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: physiographic section (third-level region in the Fenneman model of physiographic regionalization) [1]
- en: physical geography (one of the two major subfields of geography) [2]
Already fixed by ChristianKI: [5] Swpb (talk) 17:25, 30 April 2024 (UTC)
Chaco Culture World Heritage Site (Q65648486) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: archaeological culture (group of artifacts associated with a past society) [6]
- en: culture (shared aspects of a society's way of life) [7]
- en: pattern of behavior (type of animal behavior, humans included) [8]
- en: pattern (discernible spatial or temporal regularity in the world or in a man-made design) [9]
- en: regularity (abstract concept describing something that appears more than once with a certain space or time between the occurances) [10]
- en: abstract entity (entity that exists outside physical reality, including abstract objects and properties) [11] this was unexpected here as it indicates an object that exists outside physical reality !!!!!!
- en: regularity (abstract concept describing something that appears more than once with a certain space or time between the occurances) [10]
- en: pattern (discernible spatial or temporal regularity in the world or in a man-made design) [9]
- en: pattern of behavior (type of animal behavior, humans included) [8]
Jama Michalika (Q672804) is an event, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: coffeehouse (establishment that serves coffee and tea) [13]
- en: drinking establishment (business whose primary function is the serving of beverages for consumption on the premises, e.g. cafés, tea houses, inns) [14]
- en: eating or drinking establishment [15]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [16]
- en: economic activity (human activity involving the transfer of goods or services) [17]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [16]
- en: eating or drinking establishment [15]
Q107022150 is a word or phrase, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: dwelling place (type of human settlement) [24]
Q108037499 is a service, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: bus route (fixed route for transit buses) [31]
- en: transport service itinerary (regular operation of a particular path for a type of public or non-public transportation) [32]
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [33]
- en: physical process (process that can be described with physics) [34] this was unexpected here as it indicates a physical process !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: transport service (service providing transportation) [35]
- en: service (economic product that directly satisfies wants without producing a lasting asset) [36] this was unexpected here as it indicates a service !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [33]
- en: public transport route (fixed path used by a public transport service) [37]
- en: path (sequence of physical positions taken by a moving object) [38]
- en: curve (mathematical idealization of the trace left by a moving point) [39]
- en: line (general concept of a line (curved or straight)) [40]
- en: geometric shape (geometric information which remains when location, scale, orientation and reflection are removed from the description of a geometric object) [41]
- en: set (well-defined mathematical collection of distinct objects) [42]
- en: class (mathematical collection of sets that can be defined based on a property of its members (set theory)) [43]
- en: mathematical structure (additional mathematical object that, in some manner, attaches (or relates) to that set to endow it with some additional meaning or significance) [44]
- en: abstract structure (type of abstraction in science, mathematics, and philosophy) [45]
- en: abstract entity (entity that exists outside physical reality, including abstract objects and properties) [46] this was unexpected here as it indicates an object that exists outside physical reality !!!!!!!!
- en: abstract structure (type of abstraction in science, mathematics, and philosophy) [45]
- en: mathematical structure (additional mathematical object that, in some manner, attaches (or relates) to that set to endow it with some additional meaning or significance) [44]
- en: class (mathematical collection of sets that can be defined based on a property of its members (set theory)) [43]
- en: set (well-defined mathematical collection of distinct objects) [42]
- en: geometric shape (geometric information which remains when location, scale, orientation and reflection are removed from the description of a geometric object) [41]
- en: line (general concept of a line (curved or straight)) [40]
- en: curve (mathematical idealization of the trace left by a moving point) [39]
- en: path (sequence of physical positions taken by a moving object) [38]
Olaria romana da Quinta do Rouxinol (Q66815081) is an event, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: ceramics manufactory (manufactory that specialize in creating articles made of ceramic, which is a hard, brittle, heat-resistant and corrosion-resistant material, including earthenware, porcelain, and brick) [48]
- en: manufactory (manufacturing facility where products are hand-made) [49]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [50]
- en: economic activity (human activity involving the transfer of goods or services) [51]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [50]
The Fuentidueña Apse (Q24207145) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: period room (display that represents the interior design and decorative art of a particular historical social setting) [58]
- en: exhibition space (location for exhibitions) [59]
- en: exhibition area (surface area occupied by an exhibition) [60]
- en: floor area (amount of area taken up by a building or part of it) [61]
- en: area (quantity that expresses the extent of a two-dimensional surface or shape, or planar lamina, in the plane) [62]
- en: floor area (amount of area taken up by a building or part of it) [61]
- en: exhibition area (surface area occupied by an exhibition) [60]
Ausstellungsraum Klingental (Q780609) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: artist-run space (organization initiated and run by artists) [69]
- en: exhibition space (location for exhibitions) [70]
- en: exhibition area (surface area occupied by an exhibition) [71]
- en: floor area (amount of area taken up by a building or part of it) [72]
- en: area (quantity that expresses the extent of a two-dimensional surface or shape, or planar lamina, in the plane) [73]
- en: floor area (amount of area taken up by a building or part of it) [72]
- en: exhibition area (surface area occupied by an exhibition) [71]
Nelson's Ship in a Bottle (Q57838673) is a general industry, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: ship model (scale reproduction of a ship) [80]
- en: industry (group of firms that produce a closely related set of raw materials, goods, or services) [81] this was unexpected here as it indicates a general industry !!!!!!!
Giger Bar, Chur (Q16910525) is an event, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: Giger bar (Bar themed and modelled by the Swiss artist H. R. Giger) [83]
- en: bar (establishment serving alcoholic beverages for consumption on the premises) [84]
- en: food establishment (food-related business that offers food) [85]
- en: eating or drinking establishment [86]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [87]
- en: economic activity (human activity involving the transfer of goods or services) [88]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [87]
- en: eating or drinking establishment [86]
- en: food establishment (food-related business that offers food) [85]
en: border guard (government agency) [95]
- en: military branch (subdivision of the armed forces of a sovereign nation) [96]
Fixed [102]. (As a type of organization, it is abstract, but it is not a field of work.) Swpb (talk) 16:43, 15 May 2024 (UTC)
Minoh Brewery (Q11603175) is an event, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: brewery (business that makes and sells beer) [103]
- en: food manufacturer (company that produces foods) [104]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [105]
- en: economic activity (human activity involving the transfer of goods or services) [106]
- en: business (organization undertaking commercial, industrial, or professional activity) [105]
Tehachapi Loop (Q1126676) is a physical process, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: railway line (constructional unit in rail transport, the route or way of rail tracks between defined locations) [113]
- en: rail track (rail line) [114]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [115]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [116]
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [117]
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [118]
- en: physical process (process that can be described with physics) [119] this was unexpected here as it indicates a physical process !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [118]
- en: intentional human activity (human activity driven by purposeful motives) [120] this was unexpected here as it indicates an intentional human activity !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [117]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [116]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [115]
Polinka (Q16589533) is a physical process, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: gondola lift (aerial transport by means of cable cabins attached onto a circulating haul rope that moves continuously around a looped track) [123]
- en: aerial lift (means of cable transport in which cabins, cars, gondolas or open chairs are hauled above the ground by means of one or more cables) [124]
- en: cableway (any of a variety of transportation systems relying on cables to pull vehicles along or lower them at a steady rate, or a vehicle on these systems) [125]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [126]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [127]
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [128]
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [129]
- en: physical process (process that can be described with physics) [130] this was unexpected here as it indicates a physical process !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [129]
- en: intentional human activity (human activity driven by purposeful motives) [131] this was unexpected here as it indicates an intentional human activity !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [128]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [127]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [126]
- en: cableway (any of a variety of transportation systems relying on cables to pull vehicles along or lower them at a steady rate, or a vehicle on these systems) [125]
en: urban cableway [132]
- en: cableway (any of a variety of transportation systems relying on cables to pull vehicles along or lower them at a steady rate, or a vehicle on these systems) [133]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [134]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [135]
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [136]
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [137]
- en: physical process (process that can be described with physics) [138] this was unexpected here as it indicates a physical process !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: motion (change in position of an object over time; a body is said to be in motion if it changes its position or orientation with respect to its immediate surroundings) [137]
- en: intentional human activity (human activity driven by purposeful motives) [139] this was unexpected here as it indicates an intentional human activity !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: material flow (transportation of raw materials, pre-fabricates, parts, components, integrated objects and final products as a flow of entities) [136]
- en: transport (human-directed movement of things or people between locations) [135]
- en: rail and rope guided transport (mode of transport bound to a track such as classical rail track, monorail track, maglev track or hanging rope) [134]
Colegio San Bartolomé La Merced (Q19018824) is a word or phrase, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: name (word or phrase used for identification) [142]
- en: word or phrase (sequence of one or more words) [143] this was unexpected here as it indicates a word or phrase !!!
Orpheus (Q114809870) is art (field of work, not the resulting work), according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: architectural sculpture (type of sculpture) [145]
- en: public art (genre of art that is created to be in a public space) [146]
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [147]
- en: art (field of work focused on creating expressive work intended to be appreciated for its beauty or emotional power (use Q838948 for the resulting work)) [148] this was unexpected here as it indicates art (field of work, not the resulting work) !!!
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [147]
Alaska Peninsula (Q60064) is a word or phrase, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
Unexpected type Q113382977 undocumented format
The Geysers (Q3109025) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: geothermal energy (thermal energy generated and stored in the Earth) [157]
- en: sustainable energy (energy usage that meets the needs of the present without compromising the needs of future generations) [158]
memorial for Karl Liebknecht (Q32653671) is art (field of work, not the resulting work), according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: medallion (round or oval decoration used in architecture) [164]
- en: architectural sculpture (type of sculpture) [165]
- en: public art (genre of art that is created to be in a public space) [166]
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [167]
- en: art (field of work focused on creating expressive work intended to be appreciated for its beauty or emotional power (use Q838948 for the resulting work)) [168] this was unexpected here as it indicates art (field of work, not the resulting work) !!!
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [167]
- en: public art (genre of art that is created to be in a public space) [166]
Santissima Annunziata (Q37894838) (church building) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: confraternity (generally a Roman Catholic or Orthodox voluntary association of lay people) [170]
- en: Sodality (also a lay organization in the Roman Catholic Church) [171]
- en: sodality (non-kin group organized for a specific purpose and frequently spanning villages or towns) [172]
- en: social organization (pattern of relationships between and among individuals and social groups) [173]
- en: pattern (discernible spatial or temporal regularity in the world or in a man-made design) [174]
- en: regularity (abstract concept describing something that appears more than once with a certain space or time between the occurances) [175]
- en: abstract entity (entity that exists outside physical reality, including abstract objects and properties) [176] this was unexpected here as it indicates an object that exists outside physical reality !!!!!!
- en: regularity (abstract concept describing something that appears more than once with a certain space or time between the occurances) [175]
- en: pattern (discernible spatial or temporal regularity in the world or in a man-made design) [174]
- en: social organization (pattern of relationships between and among individuals and social groups) [173]
- en: sodality (non-kin group organized for a specific purpose and frequently spanning villages or towns) [172]
Correct as is, same reason as Q64555514 above. Swpb (talk) 18:37, 8 May 2024 (UTC)
Statue of John of Nepomuk (Q38052803) is art (field of work, not the resulting work), according to Wikidata ontology
edit
Unexpected type Q105213328 undocumented format
- en: religious sculpture as genre (genre of sculpture with religious themes) [177] this was unexpected here as it indicates a religious sculpture (genre) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This one is captured by classification.js by the "abstract entity" / "concrete entity" disjointness constraint, see screenshot thumb (This screenshot . It's pretty clear that there is a problem here as "art" is a subclass of process but here "statue" is the result of the process and not the process itself. There is also a problem that "process" is classified as "subclass of abstact entity" but if it's a sequence of event it's concrete. It think that I saw @ChristianKl:did a few edits recently about the "process" / "activity" items, not sure of what was done but it might be interesting to discuss this together in cas this triggered this problem.
If art is a process, then it's definitely not abstract. If a genre is a class of work, then a class of statue is not abstract either. There is definitely a problem here between the conflation of art as a practice / process and a class of works. author TomT0m / talk page 11:00, 21 April 2024 (UTC)
- @TomT0m: This has nothing to do with my edits. My edits were about having a metaclass for activity where activities are a process with agents.
- @ChristianKl: I'm not sure about that, activities are a kind of stuff you do regularly. Maybe I'm the one putting this as a metaclass with that reasoning. You can paint one time without being a painter, but some people paint for a living. "painting" is just an action / process, with an agent and a result. But "painting" as an activity, is that thing repeated over and over, for a living or for fun. So for me it makes total sense to put activity as a metaclass. It's the class of all things someone can practice regularly, for profession for example. It's different from "painting" who is just a subclass of "process" or "action" or something like that. author TomT0m / talk page 17:35, 21 April 2024 (UTC)
- Our item activity (Q1914636) doesn't seem to be limited to repeated vs. one-time events in any language as far as I can tell, and in English at least, an "activity" can certainly be something you only do once. The distinction from process (Q3249551) seems to be purely about the presence of a causative agent. Swpb (talk) 18:05, 23 April 2024 (UTC)
- @Mateusz Konieczny, Swpb: seem to have created a distinction between religious sculpture as object (Q116445901) and religious sculpture as genre (Q16675884) and the wrong one was used here. The naming of those violates our help:label policy but I see a benefit of naming those items this way, so our label policy should likely be changed to be more compatible with it. ChristianKl ❪✉❫ 16:10, 21 April 2024 (UTC)
- Oh yes, I do remember it now. I created it without systematic review of already tagged Wikidata objects so likely may are wrong. (I am pretty sure that creating such distinction was a good idea, but I am not Wikidata expert at all, so maybe I was wrong) Mateusz Konieczny (talk) 16:44, 21 April 2024 (UTC)
what is that?
edit
Is it educational platform or programming language? Or business? Ontology, description, linked wikipedia page disagree
https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q22909519
- Split: Tynker (Q22909519) is the development environment (software, not language, though it includes its own language) and Tynker (Q125940145) is the company. Swpb (talk) 17:57, 15 May 2024 (UTC)
- Edited also in OSM Mateusz Konieczny (talk) 19:21, 15 May 2024 (UTC)
beginning of time (Q63616414) is an object that exists outside physical reality, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: clock face (part of a non-digital clock that displays the time) [178]
- en: measurement scale (graduated measurement scheme developed for a phenomenon) [179]
Fixed [182] Swpb (talk) 19:59, 24 April 2024 (UTC)
Löwin (Q121323215) is art (field of work, not the resulting work), according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: animal sculpture (artistic genre of reproducing animals in sculpture) [183]
- en: animal art (artistic theme of reproducing animals in art) [184]
- en: figurative art (art that depicts real object sources) [185]
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [186]
- en: art (field of work focused on creating expressive work intended to be appreciated for its beauty or emotional power (use Q838948 for the resulting work)) [187] this was unexpected here as it indicates art (field of work, not the resulting work) !!!!!!
- en: visual arts (practice of art which creates works that are primarily visual in nature) [186]
- en: figurative art (art that depicts real object sources) [185]
Q124429211 is a construction (as economic activity), according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: rammed earth building (building whose walls are constructed from tamped earth) [189]
- en: mud building (building made mainly of mud or clay) [190]
Police Broadcasting Service (Q6701894) is a science, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: public radio (radio format) [194]
- en: public broadcasting (electronic media outlets whose primary mission is public service) [195]
- en: public service (service provided by a government to people living within its jurisdiction) [196]
- en: service (economic product that directly satisfies wants without producing a lasting asset) [197] this was unexpected here as it indicates a service !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- en: broadcasting (distribution of audio and video content to a dispersed audience via any audio or visual mass communications medium) [198]
- en: public disclosing (in communication, to broadcast a message without direct feedback from the audience) [199]
- en: public service (service provided by a government to people living within its jurisdiction) [196]
- en: radio broadcasting (distribution of audio content to a dispersed audience via any audio mass communications medium) [202]
- en: broadcast engineering (field of electrical engineering, and now to some extent computer engineering and information technology, which deals with radio and television broadcasting) [203]
- en: electrical engineering (field of engineering that deals with electricity) [204]
- en: engineering (applied science) [205]
- en: applied science (discipline that applies existing scientific knowledge to develop more practical applications) [206]
- en: science (systematic system that builds and organizes knowledge, and the set of knowledge produced by this system) [207] this was unexpected here as it indicates a science !!!!
- en: applied science (discipline that applies existing scientific knowledge to develop more practical applications) [206]
- en: engineering (applied science) [205]
- en: electrical engineering (field of engineering that deals with electricity) [204]
- en: broadcast engineering (field of electrical engineering, and now to some extent computer engineering and information technology, which deals with radio and television broadcasting) [203]
Missouri Botanical Garden (Q1852803) is a service, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: online database (database accessible from a network, including from the Internet) [210]
- en: website (set of related web pages served from a single web domain) [211] this was unexpected here as it indicates a website !!!!
Rainbow Village (Q22814370) is a genre, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: street art (art that is public and temporary in public spaces) [213]
Colonia Murri (Q125361729) is an intentional human activity, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
Unexpected type Q123154102 undocumented format
- en: summer camp (supervised program for children or teenagers conducted during the summer months) [217]
Mural Nelson Mandela (Q109331485) is a genre, according to Wikidata ontology
edit
en: graffiti (writing or drawing etched, scratched, scribbled, or sprayed (often, but not always illicitly) on a wall or other surface in a public place) [221]
- en: street art (art that is public and temporary in public spaces) [222]
Bisalhães black pottery (Q48863054) classified as an object that exists outside physical reality
editThe descriptions show the item as referring to the practice of creating the pieces, rather than the pieces themselves, so this is correct. Swpb (talk) 19:22, 24 June 2024 (UTC)