Open main menu

User talk:Bencemac

About this board

Previous discussion was archived at User talk:Bencemac/Archive 1 on 2018-09-03.

Summary by Bencemac

thanks for respecting my wish

Natuur12 (talkcontribs)

What do you propose? I was still in the process of arranging everything properly. Some wiki's discus the position, others choose to create a list of ministers. Those two aren't exactly the same and should be separated. Also, I kindly request that you use basic chivalry and use my talk page when merging an item, properly motivating an edit. I understand that administrators are busy but that isn't an excuse to skip basic communications.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)
Natuur12 (talkcontribs)

Perhaps I didn't communicate clearly. Some Wikipedia article entries qualify as a Wikimedia list article while others don't. That's what I was trying to sort out before you cut my efforts short. Could you please direct me to a relevant policy page about mixing list articles with non list articles in Wikidata items? That way I can do some reading up.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)
Natuur12 (talkcontribs)

Repeating the same argument over and over without addressing my point isn't very helpful. I'm not a Wikidata regular and therefor everything takes a little bit more time so you merged my work in progress. Now I'm asking either: "how I can solve what I was trying to solve in a more efficient way"or "is there a relevant policy that explains that Wikimedia lists and non list articles about a political position should be mixed in the same item". Could you please address my question instead of repeating yourself?

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

I explained what I followed when I merged the duplicate item. I do not know what more you want from me, so I close this discussion.

Palotabarát (talkcontribs)

Szia! Szerintem ennek nincs hivatalos weboldala: Q63247361 Weboldala magának a nagykövetségnek van, és annak elemén szerepel is: Q63247361 Így viszont hibaüzenetet ad, hogy két helyen szerepel a tulajdonság értéke. Visszavonnám, ha nem bánod.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)
Palotabarát (talkcontribs)

Ha jól értem, az az általános probléma, hogy ezeket a x ország y országi nagykövete elemeket nem ismeri el beosztásnak/pozíciónak. Ez kb. egy hónapja jelentkező figyelmeztetés (kb. 3-4 hónapja foglalkozom a diplomatákkal, és korábban nem volt ez a hibajelzés). Egyelőre azzal próbálok védekezni, hogy az ilyen elemeknél az alosztálya ennek tulajdonsághoz beírom azt is, hogy Q4164871 (hogy a fenébe kell ide rendesen linkelni, hogy a linkszöveg is látszódjék?). Szóval beírom ezt a pozíciót, de ez azért hülyeség szerintem, mert mindegyiknél szerepel az is, hogy Q121998, ami már önmagában is Q4164871. Korábban nem volt ezekkel gond, és nem csak a magyar relációkat érinti. És természetesen azoknál a személyeknél, akik ezeket a stallumokat viselik a beosztás tulajdonságban, szintén megjelent a hibajelzés. Kösz, hogy felvetetted a problémát, remélem találnak megoldást és nem kell ezerszám beleírni az elemekbe a pozíció tulajdonságot (ha már egyszer maga a nagykövet is az).

Palotabarát (talkcontribs)

Ja, és így néz ki, ha szerepel az elem alosztályában külön is a pozíció: Q63431749

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

Ha sablonként linkeled (forrásszöveg módban egyszerűbb), akkor látszik a címke is: Douglas Adams (Q42). Nem mi vagyunk az egyetlenek, akik nem értik, miért fut le hibával a kikötés. ambassador of Hungary to Belgium (Q63247361) azóta javítva lett, remélem sikerül egy univerzális megoldást találni a problémára (helyi megoldást nekem is menne, de inkább valami állandóra lenne szükség).

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

Fortunella is an invalid taxon and kumquat's valid taxon name is Citrus japonica.

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

Look at the article in the English Wikipedia. Fortunella is an inaccurately applied, outdated scientific name.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

Stop recycling items and deleting valid sitelinks, statements.

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

The valid sitelinks were moved to the valid item. Citrus japonica. Fortunella is a synonym. The "vandalim" label is ridiculous.

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

The majority of the cited sources indicate that the sole species of the monotypic taxon Fortunella, the Fortunella japonica, is the synonym of the Citrus japonica.

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

What you referred to as "vandalism" was a constructive contribution.

196.245.151.69 (talkcontribs)

Read en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kumquat starting with "Kumquats (or cumquats in Australian English, /ˈkʌmkwɒt/; Citrus japonica)" and also explaining that "Recent phylogenetic analysis suggests they do indeed fall within Citrus."

Funtertainer (talkcontribs)

This page was deleted and reason was stated as Spam/Advertisement.

I believe this was an error and will need yo to review it please.

No advertisement was done and how it could be categorized as spam is not understood, kindly shed light on this.


Thank you.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

These items do not fulfil WD:N and the links suggest me that they were created for promoting purposes.

Funtertainer (talkcontribs)

Thanks for the response, however some of the links are basically online news or blogs that reported the launch of the media company and some press releases about it.

Many are references to it in some news websites across the internet.


The media company and founder are both well known across Kuwait and india which are the main coverage area of the digital news agency. A basic review will show this page passes Notability criterion 2 and 3:

  1. It refers to an instance of a clearly identifiable conceptual or material entity. The entity must be notable, in the sense that it can be described using serious and publicly available references. (for the media company).
  2. It fulfills some structural need, for example: it is needed to make statements made in other items more useful (For the CEO's page that was also deleted - Q64968517).

A review of the page and possibly reversal of deletion will be highly appreciated.

unknown PhD student with a "funny" name

4
RennesBow (talkcontribs)

I used the name on social networks to respect his privacy. Is it necessary to recreate the page with its real name?

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

Why would he be notable?

RennesBow (talkcontribs)

I do not know, what is "notable"? He is a student PhD and book publisher so I think he is juste as noteworthy as many other peoples on Wikidata, is not it?

Bencemac (talkcontribs)
MCC214 (talkcontribs)

Hello, Bencemac. Check your email—you've got mail!

1997kB (talkcontribs)
Bencemac (talkcontribs)

Done, please confirm.

Eurohunter (talkcontribs)

Hello. What was in this item? I probably forgot to fill it.

Bencemac (talkcontribs)

The talk page contained only a version number which was outdated.

Eurohunter (talkcontribs)

I didn't noticed it's talk page. Thanks.

Wipur (talkcontribs)
Bencemac (talkcontribs)

The English one used dashes till you changed it. If I remember correctly, the uni uses dashes IRL but feel free to change it. Now I cannot show you a proper source.

Wipur (talkcontribs)
Taketa (talkcontribs)
Bencemac (talkcontribs)

Thank you! I have closed the ticket.

Return to the user page of "Bencemac".