Open main menu

Wikidata:Property proposal/animal water well

Animal water wellEdit

   Not done
Descriptionis a property of a water well that says whether there is a separat "bucket" for animals like dogs/sheep/cows to drink
Data typeString
Domainproperty
Allowed valueslist or range of allowed values
Exampledog bucket available
Planned useset it on water wells of the city of Zürich
See alsowater well (Q43483)

MotivationEdit

Of the 1200 water wells of Zürich, a significant share has an extra "bucket"/bassin/... where animals can drink.

The property is meant to mark the ones with that and the ones without

DiscussionEdit

in OSM, there is apparently a key for fountains with a dog bowl is "dog=yes"

The term "animal water well" is too general. Whether a fountain has a dish for dogs or a trough for horses are fundamentally different things. Some fountains may have both. With this in mind, it makes sense to introduce two properties. Matthew (talk) 08:15, 18 May 2018 (UTC)

  Comment Wikidata is not OSM, and in fact (from recent discussion on Project Chat) it sounds like OSM doesn't want wikidata to import things anyway. Do we actually have items in wikidata for any substantial fraction (or any?) of "the 1200 water wells of Zürich"? ArthurPSmith (talk) 17:41, 18 May 2018 (UTC)